Why Breast Implant Revision May Be Needed
Changes to the breasts are natural over time, and those with implants are no exception. Life events such as ageing, weight fluctuations, pregnancy, and hormonal changes continue to affect the breast tissue and implants. There are various reasons why revision surgery may be appropriate.
1. Size Change
Preferences may shift over time due to lifestyle changes, body composition evolution, or personal aesthetic goals. Some patients seek smaller implants to address discomfort or achieve a more natural appearance, whilst others may desire larger implants for increased fullness.
Dr Turner uses Tissue-Based Planning combined with Vectra 3D imaging to help ensure the new implant size aligns with the patient’s chest wall dimensions and skin elasticity, which may help reduce the risk of complications such as bottoming out or rippling.
Note: Size change alone is considered a cosmetic procedure and does not qualify for Medicare rebates.
2. Implant Rupture
Implant rupture occurs when the outer shell of a breast implant breaks, causing the implant’s contents to leak.
- Saline implants: Rupture is usually noticeable because the breast quickly deflates as the saline is absorbed by the body.
- Silicone implants: Modern cohesive gel implants may experience ‘silent ruptures’ where the silicone remains contained within the scar tissue capsule, causing no immediate visible changes.
An MRI scan, which may be rebated by Medicare when referred by a specialist, can confirm rupture. Revision surgery involves removal of the ruptured implant and typically replacement with a modern, TGA-approved cohesive gel implant.
3. Capsular Contracture
Capsular contracture is the most common complication following breast augmentation surgery. It occurs when the scar tissue (capsule) that naturally forms around the implant tightens excessively, potentially causing the breast to become hard, painful, or misshapen.
Capsular contracture severity is classified using the Baker Grading System:
- Grade I: Breast soft, implant not palpable (normal)
- Grade II: Breast somewhat firm; implant palpable but not visible
- Grade III: Breast firm; visible firmness and distortion
- Grade IV: Breast hard, painful, with significant distortion
Modern capsular contracture rates have significantly decreased, with current estimates around 5% within 10 years post-surgery. Risk factors include smoking and vaping (which may double the risk), pregnancy, and delayed wound healing complications.
Dr Turner typically performs a total capsulectomy (complete removal of the fibrous capsule) combined with a plane change technique, placing the new implant in a fresh, unscarred tissue plane to help reduce recurrence risk.
4. Implant Malposition
Implant malposition refers to implants that have shifted out of their intended position within the breast pocket, resulting in abnormal appearance or asymmetry. This can occur due to surgical technique issues, implant characteristics, natural body changes over time, or the weight of the implant causing migration.
Revision surgery involves repositioning the implant and reconstructing the breast pocket. Dr Turner often uses the Internal Bra technique to hold the implant in the correct anatomical position long-term.
5. Symmastia
Symmastia occurs when breast implants are placed too close together, causing the skin between the breasts to stretch or detach from the chest wall. This eliminates the natural separation between the breasts and creates the appearance of merged breasts.
This condition is often caused by over-dissection of the breast pocket during surgery or the use of implants that are too large for the patient’s chest. Revision surgery involves complex pocket reconstruction to reestablish the medial boundary of each breast pocket.
6. Wide Cleavage
Wide cleavage occurs when implants are positioned too far apart, resulting in a noticeable gap between the breasts. This may occur due to the patient’s natural anatomy, improper implant placement, or an implant that is too small for the chest wall.
Treatment options include repositioning the implants closer together or adding fat grafting to the cleavage area to help achieve better fullness.
7. Double Bubble Deformity
Double bubble deformity occurs when the breast implant shifts below the natural inframammary fold (the crease where the breast meets the chest), creating a visible second fold. This can distort the breast’s appearance, making the lower part appear unnatural.
Correction typically requires adjusting the implant position, reconstructing the breast fold using the Internal Bra technique, and potentially fat grafting to camouflage the second fold.
8. Waterfall Effect
The waterfall effect occurs when the natural breast tissue sags or droops over the implant, creating a discrepancy between the position of the breast tissue and the implant. This typically develops due to ageing, weight fluctuations, or pregnancy.
Revision surgery for the waterfall effect often involves a breast lift (mastopexy) to reposition the breast tissue, combined with implant adjustment to help restore alignment.
9. Animation Deformity
Animation deformity occurs when breast implants placed under the chest muscle (submuscular) move or distort visibly when the pectoral muscles are flexed. This can be aesthetically displeasing and uncomfortable during physical activities.
The standard approach for correction is plane conversion from submuscular to prepectoral placement. Dr Turner’s technique involves carefully releasing the pectoralis major muscle from the implant, creating a new prepectoral pocket, and placing the implant in the new position with appropriate support.
Breast Implant Removal (Explant Surgery)
Breast implant removal, also known as explant surgery, is a procedure in which breast implants are surgically removed. Patients may choose removal for various reasons, including changes in aesthetic preferences, discomfort from ageing implants, development of complications, or health concerns.
Breast Implant Illness (BII)
Breast implant illness refers to a collection of diverse, non-specific symptoms that some patients with breast implants experience. The TGA and healthcare providers acknowledge these symptoms as systemic symptoms associated with breast implants (SSBI).
Commonly reported symptoms include:
- Chronic fatigue
- Joint and muscle pain
- Cognitive symptoms (brain fog, memory difficulties)
- Headaches
- Skin issues
- Anxiety or mood changes
Research has shown that many patients experience significant symptom improvement following implant removal and capsulectomy, though results vary between individuals.
Capsulectomy Approaches
Partial Capsulectomy: Removes only the problematic portions of the capsule whilst leaving healthy tissue intact. This approach involves shorter surgery time and faster recovery.
Total Capsulectomy: Complete removal of the entire fibrous capsule surrounding the implant. This is typically performed for capsular contracture, implant rupture, or BII concerns. The excised tissue is sent for histopathology examination.
En Bloc Capsulectomy: A specialised technique where the implant and entire capsule are removed as one intact unit. This approach may be appropriate for certain patients, though it requires a larger incision and may not always be technically feasible depending on capsule adherence.
Surgical Techniques
Dr Turner utilises a range of advanced surgical techniques to address the specific challenges of revision surgery.
The Internal Bra Technique
The Internal Bra is a critical component of Dr Turner’s revision strategy, particularly for correcting bottoming out or supporting implants in patients with compromised tissue elasticity.
This technique creates a hammock-like support structure within the breast pocket to reinforce the inframammary fold and lateral walls. It may utilise:
- Biocompatible mesh scaffolds: Materials such as Tiloop or Galaflex are sutured to the fascia and breast tissue. Over 12-18 months, the mesh dissolves whilst stimulating the body to create a new, organised collagen layer that provides long-term support.
- Suture techniques: Heavy gauge permanent or long-lasting sutures used to plicate the capsule and define the fold in less severe cases.
Implant Exchange
Implant exchange involves the removal of existing breast implants and insertion of new ones, which may differ in size, shape, or material. The new implants can be placed in the same breast pocket or, if necessary, in a newly created one to achieve better positioning.
Pocket Revision
Pocket revision involves modifying the breast pocket to either tighten or adjust the capsule. This technique is commonly used to correct wide cleavage, symmastia, or bottoming out.
The breast implant pocket may also be changed from a subglandular (above the muscle) position to a submuscular (below the muscle) position or vice versa. This plane change can provide different tissue coverage and may help reduce certain complications.
Breast Lift (Mastopexy)
A breast lift may be performed in combination with implant revision to address sagging or drooping. Excess skin is removed, and the breast tissue is lifted and reshaped. The nipple and areola may also be repositioned to a more central location on the breast mound.
Fat Grafting
Fat grafting involves harvesting fat from areas such as the abdomen, thighs, or flanks using liposuction. The fat is then processed and injected into the breast to add volume, smooth rippling, or improve tissue coverage over the implant.
Implant Selection
Dr Turner uses TGA-approved, high-quality implants with established safety profiles and longitudinal clinical data.
Mentor Implants
Dr Turner predominantly utilises Mentor breast implants, which have over 40 years of manufacturing experience and FDA approval. Mentor implants feature:
- Siltex surface: A low-textured (micro-textured) surface that provides gentle tissue adherence to help stabilise the implant and reduce the risk of rotation, whilst maintaining a favourable safety profile compared to older macro-textured surfaces.
- MemoryGel technology: Cohesive silicone gel that maintains its shape even if the shell is compromised, significantly reducing the risk of silicone migration.
- Warranty support: Mentor offers a lifetime replacement policy for confirmed rupture, providing additional peace of mind for patients.
Motiva Implants
Dr Turner also uses Motiva implants, which feature:
- Nanotextured surface (SilkSurface): An advanced surface technology designed to promote tissue integration whilst minimising inflammatory response.
- Progressive gel: Cohesive silicone that aims to provide a natural feel and movement.
- Ergonomic designs: Implant options that may adapt to body position and movement.
Choosing the Right Implant
The choice between Mentor Siltex and Motiva nanotextured implants depends on individual patient factors, including anatomy, tissue characteristics, and aesthetic goals. Dr Turner will discuss the most appropriate implant option for your specific situation during your consultation.
Medicare Coverage
Medicare rebates are available for certain medical complications but are strictly regulated. A valid GP referral is required for all Medicare claims.
Medical Indications (Potential Medicare Rebates)
- Capsular contracture (Grades III & IV) with documented hardness, pain, or disfigurement
- Implant rupture or leakage confirmed via imaging
- Implant extrusion
- Infection
- Severe implant migration or malposition
- BIA-ALCL concerns
Cosmetic Indications (No Medicare Rebate)
- Size change due to personal preference
- Shape change for aesthetic reasons
- Post-pregnancy aesthetic changes without documented medical complication
Relevant MBS Item Numbers
- Item 45548: Breast implant removal as an independent procedure
- Item 45551: Removal with capsulectomy (excision of at least 50% of capsule; specimen sent for histopathology)
- Item 45553: Removal and replacement (highly restricted; requires original implant for breast cancer/developmental abnormality OR documentation that removal alone would cause unacceptable deformity)
For more detailed information about Medicare coverage, see our guide: Will Medicare Cover My Breast Implant Removal?
Recovery After Breast Implant Revision
Recovery from revision surgery is typically longer than primary augmentation due to the more extensive tissue dissection often required. Most patients can return to office-based work after approximately two weeks, with light exercise resuming around week six. Full recovery, including return to high-impact exercise and upper body workouts, generally occurs by week twelve. Final aesthetic results typically emerge between six to twelve months as implants settle and scars fade.
For comprehensive recovery information, see: Recovery After Breast Augmentation Surgery
Risks and Complications
As with any surgery, breast implant revision carries potential risks. These will be discussed in detail during your consultation with Dr Turner.
General surgical risks include swelling, bruising, infection, bleeding, scarring, and anaesthetic risks. Procedure-specific risks include asymmetry, changes in nipple sensation, recurrent capsular contracture, implant malposition, and the potential need for further revision surgery.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if I need breast implant revision surgery?
Signs that may indicate revision surgery is needed include visible changes to breast shape or symmetry, hardening of the breast tissue (which may suggest capsular contracture), pain or discomfort, visible rippling, implant displacement, or a noticeable change in size (which may indicate rupture in saline implants). If you are experiencing any of these concerns, a consultation with a Specialist Plastic Surgeon can help determine whether revision is appropriate.
How long do breast implants last before needing replacement?
Breast implants are not lifetime devices. Whilst there is no set expiration date, many patients may require revision surgery at some point. Some implants may last 10-20 years or longer without issue, whilst others may require earlier intervention due to complications. Regular monitoring and follow-up appointments can help identify potential issues before they become significant concerns.
Is breast implant revision more complex than the original surgery?
Yes, revision surgery is generally more complex than primary breast augmentation. The surgeon must work with existing scar tissue, potentially altered anatomy, and may need to address complications from the previous procedure. This is why selecting a surgeon with specific experience in revision procedures is important.
Can I change my implant size during revision surgery?
Yes, many patients choose to change their implant size during revision surgery. Whether increasing or decreasing size, Dr Turner uses Tissue-Based Planning and 3D imaging to help ensure the new implant is appropriate for your current anatomy and tissue characteristics. Significant size changes may require additional procedures such as a breast lift.
What is the difference between capsulectomy and capsulotomy?
A capsulectomy involves the surgical removal of the scar tissue capsule surrounding the implant, either partially or completely. A capsulotomy involves making incisions in the capsule to release tightness without removing it. The appropriate approach depends on the reason for revision and will be discussed during your consultation.
Will I need drains after revision surgery?
Drains may be required following revision surgery, particularly if extensive capsulectomy is performed. When used, drains typically remain in place for several days to help prevent fluid accumulation. Dr Turner will advise whether drains are likely to be needed based on your specific surgical plan.
Can revision surgery be performed through the same incision?
In many cases, revision surgery can be performed through the existing scar from your previous breast augmentation. However, depending on the complexity of the revision and the techniques required, additional or alternative incision sites may be necessary. This will be discussed during your consultation.
What is the Internal Bra technique and when is it used?
The Internal Bra technique involves creating an internal support structure using biocompatible mesh or sutures to reinforce the breast pocket and hold the implant in position. It is commonly used in revision cases involving bottoming out, implant malposition, or when tissue support has been compromised. The mesh gradually dissolves over 12-18 months whilst stimulating the body to create its own supportive collagen layer.
How soon after my original surgery can I have revision?
The timing of revision surgery depends on the reason for the procedure. For elective changes such as size adjustment, it is generally advisable to wait at least 6-12 months for tissues to fully heal and settle. For complications such as infection or rupture, earlier intervention may be necessary. Dr Turner will assess your individual situation and recommend appropriate timing.
Will my health insurance cover breast implant revision?
Private health insurance may provide some coverage for breast implant revision if performed in a private hospital, depending on your policy and level of cover. Medicare rebates may apply if the revision addresses a documented medical complication rather than cosmetic concerns. Our team can provide you with item numbers to check with your health fund prior to surgery.
What happens to my breasts if I choose explant without replacement?
Following implant removal without replacement, the appearance of your breasts will depend on several factors including your natural breast tissue volume, skin elasticity, how long the implants were in place, and the size of the implants removed. Some patients may benefit from a breast lift performed at the same time to address excess skin. Dr Turner can discuss expected outcomes during your consultation.
Can capsular contracture recur after revision surgery?
Yes, capsular contracture can potentially recur following revision surgery, though techniques such as total capsulectomy combined with a plane change may help reduce this risk. Factors that may increase recurrence risk include smoking, infection, and haematoma. Following post-operative instructions carefully may help minimise this risk.
How long will I need to take off work?
Most patients can return to sedentary or office-based work within approximately two weeks following revision surgery. Those with physically demanding jobs may require four to six weeks before returning to full duties. Dr Turner will provide specific guidance based on your procedure and individual healing progress.
What type of bra should I wear after revision surgery?
A supportive surgical compression bra is typically worn continuously (day and night) for the first six weeks following surgery. This helps support the healing tissues and may assist with implant positioning. Dr Turner will provide specific instructions regarding post-operative garments based on your procedure.
Can I breastfeed after breast implant revision?
Many patients retain the ability to breastfeed following breast implant revision, though this depends on the specific surgical techniques used and whether milk ducts or nipple tissue are affected. If future breastfeeding is a concern, please discuss this with Dr Turner during your consultation so it can be factored into surgical planning.